1-3 of 12 popular logical fallacies

Abstract

Learn to spot and defeat three common logical fallacies: ad hominem attacks, straw man arguments, and false dilemmas. Winning debates start with recognizing flawed logic.

Have you ever been in an argument where someone attacked you instead of your ideas? Or did they twist your words to make you sound ridiculous? These are logical fallacies, and people use them all the time, sometimes without even knowing it. Learn these tricks so they do not catch you off guard. Let's look at three of the most common ones.

Ad Hominem: Attacking the Person

An ad hominem fallacy occurs when someone attacks you instead of addressing your argument.

Example: Imagine you're debating school uniforms. You say, "Uniforms limit student expression and don't actually improve test scores." Your opponent responds, "Well, you always dress weird anyway, so of course you'd say that."

Notice what happened? They didn't prove that uniforms work. They insulted how you dress.

How to Win: Stay calm and point out what they're doing. You might say, "Whether I dress weird or not doesn't change the facts about uniforms. Do you have evidence that they improve test scores?" This puts the focus back on the actual topic. Don't get emotional or insult them back; that's what they want. By staying logical, you show everyone watching that you have the stronger argument.

Straw Man: Fighting a Fake Argument

A straw man fallacy is when someone changes what you said into something easier to attack. They create a "straw man" version of your argument and knock that down instead of dealing with your real point.

Example: You say, "We should spend less money on new football equipment and more on arts programs." Your opponent responds, "So you hate football and want to destroy our school's sports tradition?"

That's not what you said at all! You suggested a different approach to balancing the budget, but they made it sound as if you wanted to cut football.

How to Win: Immediately clarify your actual position. Say something like, "That misrepresents what I said. I support football, but a $20,000 scoreboard is excessive when the art department can't afford basic supplies." Then restate to yourself what you said. This forces them to either address what you actually said or admit they are misrepresenting you. Either way, you come out looking honest and reasonable.

False Dilemma: The Fake Choice

A false dilemma presents only two options when more choices actually exist. It's a way of forcing you into a corner by pretending there are only two possible positions.

Example: Someone says, "Either you support building a new parking lot, or you do not care about students who drive to school."

This ignores other solutions such as shuttle buses, carpooling programs, or better bike paths. It also claims that if you disagree with their solution, you do not care about the problem.

How to Win: Point out the missing options. You could say, "That's a false choice. I care about students getting to school, but there are other solutions besides a parking lot. What about a shuttle from the community center? That would cost less and help the environment?" By breaking free of only two options, you break their trap and often present a better solution they haven't considered.

Why This Matters

These three fallacies appear everywhere: in politics, ads, social media, and daily chats. People use them because they often work, especially when dealing with those who are not aware of them.

When someone deploys these tactics against you, you can respond and keep the discussion honest. You'll earn respect for being fair and logical. You will make better decisions because you are not allowing manipulation to cloud your judgment.

The next time someone tries one of these tactics on you, take a breath, recognize what is happening, and respond with logic. That's how you win.

Stay tuned for the next 8 out of 12 logical fallacies.

Help motivate me, and help offset the cost of running a blog by buying me a coffee at:

https://buymeacoffee.com/clubtj

Visit my blog at:

https://www.quarkstochlorophyll.blog

© 2025 Tim Jackson. All Rights Reserved.